Access control: fob, card, keypad or app?

By Liam, OHMS GROUP LTD ·

Access control replaces keys with credentials that can be given, limited and taken away in seconds. It answers three questions: who can get in, when, and through which doors. It also keeps a record of who used which door, which is useful when something goes missing or a dispute needs settling.

The right set up depends on how many doors and users you have, who manages it, and how the building is used.

Types of credential

Keypads and PIN codes

Simple and cheap, and fine for a single internal door such as a store room. The weakness is that codes get shared and are rarely changed, so you never really know who has access.

Fobs and cards

Proximity fobs and cards are the most common choice. Each one belongs to a named person, can be limited to certain doors and times, and can be cancelled the moment it is lost or someone leaves. Fobs suit keyrings; cards can double as ID badges.

Phone credentials

Many systems now let users open doors with their phone over Bluetooth or through an app. They are convenient and easy to issue remotely, which suits shared offices and visitors. It is common to run phones alongside fobs, so people who prefer a fob still have one.

Biometric readers

Fingerprint and face readers remove the problem of lent credentials but involve storing biometric data, which brings extra data protection responsibilities. They tend to be reserved for higher security areas.

Standalone or networked

A standalone system controls one or two doors and is managed at the door. A networked system connects every door to software, so you can add or remove users, set time zones, and see events across the whole site, or several sites, from one place. If you have more than a few doors or a regular turnover of staff or tenants, networked systems save a great deal of time.

Door entry for blocks of flats

In residential blocks, access control usually comes with audio or video door entry. Visitors call the flat from the entrance panel, and residents answer on a handset or their phone and release the door. Trade buttons or timed codes can let post and deliveries in during set hours, and fobs for residents can be cancelled when people move out.

Fire safety comes first

Any controlled door on an escape route must let people out in an emergency. In practice that usually means:

  • A green break glass unit beside the door to release it manually
  • A link to the fire alarm so the door releases automatically when the alarm sounds
  • Locks chosen so the door fails safe, opening if the power is lost, where the fire strategy requires it
  • A simple push to exit button or handle on the inside

BS 7273-4 is the code of practice for how fire alarm systems release door locks and hold-open devices. Getting the interface right is a shared job between the access control and fire alarm installer, so using one company for both helps. Our guide to fire alarm categories explains the alarm side.

Audit trails and cameras

Networked access control records every door event. Linking it to CCTV lets you jump straight to the footage of a door at the time a fob was used, which makes investigations much quicker.

Looking after the system

Access control needs occasional attention like any other system. Locks and door closers wear, standby batteries in power supplies age, and readers on external doors take a beating from the weather. An annual service checks every door releases correctly, including on fire alarm activation, and is a good time to clear out credentials for people who have left.

Questions to answer before you choose

  1. How many doors, and which are on escape routes?
  2. How many users, and how often do they change?
  3. Who will manage users day to day?
  4. Do you need visitor or contractor access for set times?
  5. Should it work with your fire alarm, CCTV or intruder alarm?

Access control in London and Kent

We are a Paxton Registered Installer and fit fob, card and app based access control and video door entry for offices, industrial units and residential blocks, with fire alarm interfaces tested at commissioning. See our access control and door entry service, our fire alarm installation and our CCTV installation. We work across London, Maidstone and the rest of Kent. Call 01622 278762 for a free survey.

Common questions

What happens to access controlled doors in a fire?

Doors on escape routes should release automatically when the fire alarm activates, with a break glass unit beside the door for manual release.

Can we add and remove users ourselves?

Yes, with a networked system. A nominated administrator can issue and cancel fobs, cards or phone credentials from the software.

Are phone credentials secure?

They can be, and many organisations use them alongside fobs. Lost phones and leavers are handled by cancelling the credential, just like a fob.

Related

Get a free, no-obligation quote

Tell us what you need and we'll arrange a survey. No callout charge for quotations, and a fixed written price before any work starts.

Mon–Sat 7am–6pm · Based in Aylesford, Kent · Working UK-wide